Questioned by Police but Not Charged: Your Rights

8 mins read

You’re going about your normal day when the police approach you. They ask you to come down to the station to answer a few questions about an alleged crime. You comply, but once there, the interrogation feels relentless. “What were you doing last Tuesday at 3 PM?” “Where were you the night the jewelry store was robbed?”

You invoke your right to remain silent, but the questions keep coming. After hours stuck in the station, the police finally let you go. No arrest. No charges were filed. But the experience leaves you shaken.

This situation is more common than you may think. The police may question you as part of an ongoing investigation, even if you haven’t been formally accused of anything. So what should you do when the police want information but haven’t charged you with a crime?

Common Reasons Police May Question You

There are a variety of reasons why police may try to talk to you, even temporarily detain you, as part of an investigation. It does not necessarily mean you are suspected of committing a crime. Some common scenarios include:

  • You resemble or match the description of someone involved in a crime
  • Your vehicle is similar to one used in a crime
  • You were present at the scene of an incident under investigation
  • Someone made an accusation against you, even if false
  • You are considered a potential witness to an alleged offense

In cases like these, the police may try to question you or even bring you down to the station. But not being formally arrested or charged with an actual crime gives you greater legal protection.

Your Right to Remain Silent is Key

When being questioned by police, what are your rights? The 5th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution protects your right to remain silent so you cannot be compelled to say anything that might implicate yourself.

You are not required to answer the police officer’s questions during any conversation or interrogation when you have not been formally arrested or charged. Even refusing to provide basic information like your name and address is constitutionally protected in these circumstances.

If questioned by police, say politely but firmly: “Officer, I do not wish to speak with you or answer any questions.” You can also state that you want to speak with an attorney. This invokes your constitutional rights and should end the questioning.

Avoid Interrogation Without an Attorney

Police often use intense questioning and psychological tactics during interrogations to try to get suspects or persons of interest to talk or even confess. However, you have the right to have legal counsel present during any custodial interrogation.

Don’t let law enforcement try to convince you that speaking without an attorney is ‘in your best interest.’ They want to help build their case, not look out for you. Insist on having a lawyer if taken into custody or brought to the station against your will for questioning. Remember, anything you say can and will be used against you in court.

What If You’re Not Free to Leave?

So when exactly are your rights triggered when dealing with officers? It depends on whether you have been “detained” versus a casual chat.

Merely questioning you briefly on the street or asking for ID does not necessarily constitute detainment. But if a reasonable person would not feel free to leave and end the encounter, you can refuse to answer questions and ask if you are being detained.

If so, state clearly that you will not answer any questions until you speak with your attorney. At this point, the police must either formally detain you, arrest you if they have probable cause, or let you go.

Search Warrants Protect Home Privacy

Police showing up at your door may want to search your home in relation to an investigation. The 4th Amendment prohibits ‘unreasonable searches ‘, such as searching your home without a warrant or without your consent, and a legally valid search warrant is required.

You are not required to consent to a search or voluntarily let police enter without a proper warrant signed by a judge. Politely state you do not consent and will not answer more questions until you speak with your attorney. Shut the door if they don’t produce a search warrant.

When Should You Hire a Criminal Defense Lawyer?

Any encounter with police has legal implications, even if you are completely innocent. The Benjamin Durham Law Firm understands dealing with law enforcement can be stressful and confusing. Don’t jeopardize your rights by trying to reason with the police.

If contacted, questioned, detained or invited down to the station in relation to any criminal investigation, it’s vital to consult a criminal defense lawyer right away. We, at the Benjamin Durham Law Firm, are here to protect everyday citizens like you. Our experienced lawyers will stand by your side, ensuring your rights are upheld. Don’t say anything to the police until you’ve spoken with a lawyer!

Protect Your Rights With Experienced Legal Representation

Dealing with intense police questioning without counsel can be intimidating. Don’t jeopardize your future by going it alone against seasoned detectives. A top Las Vegas criminal defense lawyer serves as your shield, to help control damage and minimize any long-term legal consequences.

Benjamin Durham Law Firm believes everyone has rights when questioned by police, even if no charges are filed yet. Our Las Vegas criminal defense lawyers have 40+ years combined legal experience handling these types of cases. Don’t jeopardize your rights – call (702) 631-6111 for a free consultation now if you’ve been questioned by law enforcement.

Take back your power. Protect your future. Demand the best criminal defense alongside you for any police confrontation. Call Benjamin Durham Law Firm today.

Stay in touch to get more updates & news on Discover Tribune!

Previous Story

What Happens if You Fail a Gun Background Check?

Next Story

Motorcycle Accident Not Your Fault? Here’s What to Do Next

Latest from Blog